Is a High-Earning Employee Entitled to Overtime?

March 23, 2023

According to the Supreme Court, even a high-earning employee can be entitled to overtime if they are not paid on a salary basis.


In Helix Energy Solutions Group v. Hewitt, the Court considered the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and assessed whether a supervisor earning over $200,000 annually is entitled to overtime pay.


Helix argued that Hewitt’s “executive” status exempted him from overtime pay and placed him beyond the threshold for a “highly compensated” worker. On appeal in the 5th Circuit, the court held that the “highly compensated” metric did not apply because Hewitt was paid using a day rate, not a salary.


When the case arrived at the Supreme Court, the issue before the Justices was whether a “daily rate” pay satisfied the salary-based requirement under the FLSA.


The Court held that a salary provided “the stability and security of a regular weekly, monthly, or annual pay structure.” Helix had violated the principles of a true salary by paying Hewitt for the days on which he actually worked.


If your business has any questions on this topic or any other matters, please do not hesitate to contact the attorneys at The Royal Law Firm at 413-586-2288.

December 5, 2025
Our attorneys successfully obtained summary judgment in favor of the Defendant from the Massachusetts Appeals Court in a Wage Act and contract dispute. The Complainant alleged entitlement to a substantial variable compensation award following resignation. We demonstrated that the compensation plan made such awards discretionary and contingent on continued employment at the time of payout. The Appeals Court agreed, finding that the award did not constitute wages under the Wage Act and that the Defendant acted lawfully in denying payment. All claims were dismissed in their entirety.
By The Royal Law Firm November 5, 2025
Attorney Amy Royal has once again been selected as a Super Lawyer ! As published by Super Lawyers Amy B. Royal is a top-rated attorney, with her firm headquartered in Springfield, Massachusetts. Providing legal representation in the New England states and New York, for a variety of different issues, Amy Royal was selected to Super Lawyers for 2014 - 2016, 2019 - 2025. Attorneys like Amy B. Royal are recognized by their peers for their outstanding work and commitment to the spirit of the legal profession. Their knowledge of the law, professional work ethic, and advocacy on behalf of their clients allow them to stand out among other attorneys in the field.