Royal

National Labor Relations Board Decision on I-9 Forms Upheld

June 17, 2021
National Labor Relations Board (NLRB)

A panel of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) recently upheld a decision that employers must bargain with unions over the effects of a requirement that employees fill out new I-9 forms. 


In this case, the employer conducted an I-9 audit, and determined that it did not have proper I-9 forms for 95% of its workforce. The employer notified the employees that they needed to submit new I-9 forms and supporting documentation. When the union found out about this, it complained that it had not received prior notice about the requirement and demanded bargaining on the issue. The employer refused, and argued that it did not have to bargain with the union over its decision to resolve I-9 compliance issues. Subsequently, the union filed an unfair labor practice charge under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).


The NLRB found that requiring employees to submit a new I-9 form is a subject of mandatory bargaining because the requirement affects the terms and conditions of employment, since employees who have difficulty completing the form risk losing their jobs. Although employers must comply with federal immigration law and secure a valid I-9 for each employee, they have discretion over how to implement compliance, such as deciding the amount of time the employer would give an employee to present supporting documentation. Therefore, employers must bargain over the impact complying with the law could have on employees’ terms and conditions of employment.


This case demonstrates how even when implementing federal or state compliance, employers must consider interactions with labor laws and stay attentive to their NLRA obligations. If you need to make an adjustment to an employment practice, even if it is for state or federal compliance reasons, be sure to check with us first.


If you have any questions about this topic or any other labor and employment law matters, please feel free to contact the attorneys at The Royal Law Firm at 413-586-2288.

March 28, 2025
The Royal Law Firm was a Finalist for Best Law Firm in The Best of The Valley Readers' Poll for 2025, as published by the Valley Advocate! Thank you to everyone who voted for us, and to those of you who trust us to help you in times of need. Click here to check out all of the category winners and finalists.
March 28, 2025
The EEOC has issued guidance on what constitutes illegal DEI and its application to private employers. Employees alleging DEI-based discrimination are required to file a charge of discrimination with the EEOC to prove probable cause and be awarded a Notice of Right to Sue to pursue a suit in Federal Court under Title VII. Illegal DEI practices are when an employer or other covered entity takes any employment action influenced- in whole or in part- by race, sex, or another protected characteristic. The guidance is very clear that protected characteristics cannot have any bearing on employment action; it doesn’t matter if it’s the only factor, deciding factor, or one of many equally weighed factors. Any consideration toward a protected characteristic is illegal. Client and customer requests are not an exception unless there is a bona fide occupational qualification “reasonably necessary to the normal operation of that particular business or enterprise” in regard to religion, sex, or national origin. The limited exception of the bona fide occupational qualification is not extended to race or color. The EEOC has stated that, “depending on the facts, an employee may be able to plausibly allege or prove that a diversity or other DEI-related training created a hostile work environment by pleading or showing that the training was discriminatory in content, application, or context.” It is prudent practice to seek legal counsel to avoid prosecution under this new guidance. The attorneys at The Royal Law Firm are committed to helping employers navigate EEOC complaints and investigations. If your business has any questions on this topic or any other matters, please do not hesitate to contact the attorneys at The Royal Law Firm at 413-586-2288.
Share by: